American Flyer Trains

40 listings · $20.00–$469.99 · eBay, Walmart, UnbeatableSale.com · Prices checked November 14, 2026

Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Model:
Condition:
Retailer:

Showing 40 of 40 listings

Wide Gauge (1)

  • American Flyer No. 1453 Wide Gauge Train Set 1926 President's Special 4039 VIDEO

    American Flyer No. 1453 Wide Gauge Train Set 1926 President's Special 4039 VIDEO

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (3,865 ratings)

    $469.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay

HO Gauge (2)

  • AC Gilbert/American Flyer HO scale model train freight cars in box, 7 ea

    AC Gilbert/American Flyer HO scale model train freight cars in box, 7 ea

    Used · eBay · Seller 94.1% positive (20 ratings)

    $59.99

    +$5.78 shipping · $65.77 total

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer HO Gauge #33537 Track Cleaning Car , RARE Plastic Box

    American Flyer HO Gauge #33537 Track Cleaning Car , RARE Plastic Box

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (943 ratings)

    $73.50

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay

O Gauge (1)

  • American Flyer Lines Prewar 0 Gauge Locomotive # 1218

    American Flyer Lines Prewar 0 Gauge Locomotive # 1218

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (5,523 ratings)

    $50.00

    +$7.00 shipping · $57.00 total

    View at eBay

S Gauge (18)

  • American Flyer (Gilbert) S Gauge Missouri Pacific Stock Car No 929

    American Flyer (Gilbert) S Gauge Missouri Pacific Stock Car No 929

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (131 ratings)

    $20.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer S Gauge Steam Locomotive 287 C&NW 2-6-4 w/ Tender Analog

    American Flyer S Gauge Steam Locomotive 287 C&NW 2-6-4 w/ Tender Analog

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (26 ratings)

    $22.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer 24633 S Gauge Silver Radio Equipped Caboose

    American Flyer 24633 S Gauge Silver Radio Equipped Caboose

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (5,643 ratings)

    $29.95

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer S Gauge 283 Chicago & North Western 4-6-2 Steam Locomotive+Tender

    American Flyer S Gauge 283 Chicago & North Western 4-6-2 Steam Locomotive+Tender

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (26 ratings)

    $32.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Vtg American Flyer Postwar S Gauge 774 Floodlight Tower Top Platform Dome Socket

    Vtg American Flyer Postwar S Gauge 774 Floodlight Tower Top Platform Dome Socket

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (6,390 ratings)

    $24.99

    +$10.00 shipping · $34.99 total

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer S Gauge 716 Auto Dump Car w/Control Button and Track Trip
    eBay Top Rated Plus

    American Flyer S Gauge 716 Auto Dump Car w/Control Button and Track Trip

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.9% positive (6,441 ratings)

    $24.99

    +$10.00 shipping · $34.99 total

    View at eBay
  • Gilbert American Flyer S Gauge Red 718 New Haven/REA Mail Pickup Car 5739

    Gilbert American Flyer S Gauge Red 718 New Haven/REA Mail Pickup Car 5739

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.7% positive (1,049 ratings)

    $34.99

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer 21165 S Gauge Locomotive and Tender Tested See Description.

    American Flyer 21165 S Gauge Locomotive and Tender Tested See Description.

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.2% positive (2,017 ratings)

    $24.00

    +$12.00 shipping · $36.00 total

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer S Gauge Western Pacific California Zephyr Dining Car 6-48932

    American Flyer S Gauge Western Pacific California Zephyr Dining Car 6-48932

    New · eBay · Seller 98.1% positive (99 ratings)

    $40.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer 6-48576 S Scale Flatcar w/Mlk Cnt Gilbert

    American Flyer 6-48576 S Scale Flatcar w/Mlk Cnt Gilbert

    New · Walmart

    $52.89

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • LNL2319260 S Scale 2023 American Flyer Christmas Boxcar Model Train

    LNL2319260 S Scale 2023 American Flyer Christmas Boxcar Model Train

    New · UnbeatableSale.com

    $58.49

    Shipping not listed

    View at UnbeatableSale.com
  • American Flyer Baltimore & Ohio 3 Bay Hopper #621156 S Gauge

    American Flyer Baltimore & Ohio 3 Bay Hopper #621156 S Gauge

    New · Walmart

    $58.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer Reading 2 Bay Covered Hopper #79172 S Gauge

    American Flyer Reading 2 Bay Covered Hopper #79172 S Gauge

    New · Walmart

    $58.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer ANDERSON'S 2 Bay Covered Hopper #188 S Gauge

    American Flyer ANDERSON'S 2 Bay Covered Hopper #188 S Gauge

    New · Walmart

    $58.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer BORDENS Milk Flat CAR #1401 S Gauge

    American Flyer BORDENS Milk Flat CAR #1401 S Gauge

    New · Walmart

    $58.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer Penn Central 3 Dome Tank CAR #70755 S Gauge

    American Flyer Penn Central 3 Dome Tank CAR #70755 S Gauge

    New · Walmart

    $59.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer Norfolk & Western BOXCAR #43626 S Gauge

    American Flyer Norfolk & Western BOXCAR #43626 S Gauge

    New · Walmart

    $64.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer B&O 2 Bay Covered Hopper #630413 S Gauge

    American Flyer B&O 2 Bay Covered Hopper #630413 S Gauge

    New · Walmart

    $64.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart

Other listings (18)

  • Tested Works American Flyer  7210 Searchlight Flat Car  NICE Condition FAST Ship

    Tested Works American Flyer 7210 Searchlight Flat Car NICE Condition FAST Ship

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (2,222 ratings)

    $24.00

    +$10.80 shipping · $34.80 total

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer 593 Signal Tower Lighted Works A.C. Gilbert

    American Flyer 593 Signal Tower Lighted Works A.C. Gilbert

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,786 ratings)

    $25.79

    +$9.20 shipping · $34.99 total

    View at eBay
  • Milwaukee Flyer 45° Crossing for Post War American Flyer Trains

    Milwaukee Flyer 45° Crossing for Post War American Flyer Trains

    New · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (2,764 ratings)

    $34.99

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • 6 Vintage American Flyer Freight Train Cars,Rocket Launcher,Log,Boxcar,Gondola

    6 Vintage American Flyer Freight Train Cars,Rocket Launcher,Log,Boxcar,Gondola

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (15,196 ratings)

    $30.00

    +$20.00 shipping · $50.00 total

    View at eBay
  • Vintage American Flyer Handcar Train D&RGW A.C. Gilbert USA Custom Paint Job

    Vintage American Flyer Handcar Train D&RGW A.C. Gilbert USA Custom Paint Job

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (133 ratings)

    $50.00

    +$8.00 shipping · $58.00 total

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer A/F Florida Juice Milk CAR

    American Flyer A/F Florida Juice Milk CAR

    New · Walmart

    $58.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer 583 Electro Magnetic Crane Works.

    American Flyer 583 Electro Magnetic Crane Works.

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,786 ratings)

    $49.79

    +$9.20 shipping · $58.99 total

    View at eBay
  • LNL2219340 AF RTR American Flyer 2022 Christmas Boxcar

    LNL2219340 AF RTR American Flyer 2022 Christmas Boxcar

    New · UnbeatableSale.com

    $62.13

    Shipping not listed

    View at UnbeatableSale.com
  • American Flyer A/F Union PACIFC 3 Bay Hopper

    American Flyer A/F Union PACIFC 3 Bay Hopper

    New · Walmart

    $64.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer A/F Western Maryland 3 Bay

    American Flyer A/F Western Maryland 3 Bay

    New · Walmart

    $68.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer A/F GN 2-Bay Hopper #73313

    American Flyer A/F GN 2-Bay Hopper #73313

    New · Walmart

    $68.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • AMERICAN FLYER  NEW YORK CENTRAL 4-6-4 *HO*  LOCOMOTIVE 5318 &TENDER/RUNS GOOD

    AMERICAN FLYER NEW YORK CENTRAL 4-6-4 *HO* LOCOMOTIVE 5318 &TENDER/RUNS GOOD

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (3,428 ratings)

    $55.00

    +$14.85 shipping · $69.85 total

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer A/F Santa FE 3 Bay Covered

    American Flyer A/F Santa FE 3 Bay Covered

    New · Walmart

    $74.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer A/F SCL 50' Waffle Sided

    American Flyer A/F SCL 50' Waffle Sided

    New · Walmart

    $74.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer A/F Reading 3 Bay Covered

    American Flyer A/F Reading 3 Bay Covered

    New · Walmart

    $74.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • American Flyer # 779 Oil Drum Loader Original Box Excellent Vintage A.C. Gilbert

    American Flyer # 779 Oil Drum Loader Original Box Excellent Vintage A.C. Gilbert

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,337 ratings)

    $74.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer Train Set -302 Locomotive w Smoke & Choo-Choo, Tender & 3 Cars
    eBay Top Rated Plus

    American Flyer Train Set -302 Locomotive w Smoke & Choo-Choo, Tender & 3 Cars

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (3,623 ratings)

    $85.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Flyer A/F Conrail AUTORACK #964940

    American Flyer A/F Conrail AUTORACK #964940

    New · Walmart

    $88.84

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart

Price snapshot

Asking prices across 40 listings checked November 14, 2026, before shipping. The median is a good guide to a typical price; actual selling prices can be lower.

ModelListingsLowestMedianHighest
Wide Gauge1$469.99$469.99$469.99
HO Gauge2$59.99$66.75$73.50
O Gauge1$50.00$50.00$50.00
S Gauge18$20.00$46.45$64.84
Other listings18$24.00$63.49$88.84
All listings40$20.00$58.84$469.99