American Girl Doll Used

40 listings · $31.50–$250.00 · eBay · Prices checked November 15, 2026

Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Model:

Showing 40 of 40 listings

Custom Dolls (6)

  • Custom AMERICAN GIRL DOLL with Black /Magenta Hair & Brown Eyes Outfit 2014

    Custom AMERICAN GIRL DOLL with Black /Magenta Hair & Brown Eyes Outfit 2014

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (2,112 ratings)

    $64.97

    +$11.95 shipping · $76.92 total

    View at eBay
  • custom american girl doll julie in field trip ouffit

    custom american girl doll julie in field trip ouffit

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (83 ratings)

    $85.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American girl doll beautiful ooak repaint dark hair freckles 'Ella'

    American girl doll beautiful ooak repaint dark hair freckles 'Ella'

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (335 ratings)

    $74.99

    +$12.00 shipping · $86.99 total

    View at eBay
  • American Girl 18 in Doll Custom OOAK with Outfit

    American Girl 18 in Doll Custom OOAK with Outfit

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (275 ratings)

    $124.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Custom American Girl Doll with Black Hair, Green Eyes and Sweater Outfit!

    Custom American Girl Doll with Black Hair, Green Eyes and Sweater Outfit!

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (796 ratings)

    $160.00

    +$20.00 shipping · $180.00 total

    View at eBay
  • Custom American Girl Doll, with Dark Auburn Hair and Sweater Outfit!

    Custom American Girl Doll, with Dark Auburn Hair and Sweater Outfit!

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (796 ratings)

    $165.00

    +$20.00 shipping · $185.00 total

    View at eBay

Truly Me & Just Like You (11)

  • American Girl Truly Me 18in Doll Blue Eyes Multicolor Hair Rudolph Pajamas

    American Girl Truly Me 18in Doll Blue Eyes Multicolor Hair Rudolph Pajamas

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (599 ratings)

    $39.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Truly Me #25 Doll JLY Black-Brown Hair Brown Eyes 18" AG Retired

    American Girl Truly Me #25 Doll JLY Black-Brown Hair Brown Eyes 18" AG Retired

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (1,363 ratings)

    $40.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll JLY Brown hair & Brown Eyes Medium Skin Truly Me Earrings

    American Girl Doll JLY Brown hair & Brown Eyes Medium Skin Truly Me Earrings

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.7% positive (594 ratings)

    $44.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Truly Me Doll Brown Curly Hair Brown Eyes Medium Skin 2017

    American Girl Truly Me Doll Brown Curly Hair Brown Eyes Medium Skin 2017

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (6,044 ratings)

    $34.77

    +$12.97 shipping · $47.74 total

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Just Like You Truly Me Doll Blue Eyed Doll

    American Girl Just Like You Truly Me Doll Blue Eyed Doll

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.6% positive (17,497 ratings)

    $35.00

    +$14.00 shipping · $49.00 total

    View at eBay
  • Pleasant Company American Girl Doll Vintage Girl of Today JLY #12 Blonde READ

    Pleasant Company American Girl Doll Vintage Girl of Today JLY #12 Blonde READ

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,905 ratings)

    $49.26

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl 18" Doll Truly Me Blonde Hair Brown Eyes Julie  #78

    American Girl 18" Doll Truly Me Blonde Hair Brown Eyes Julie #78

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (705 ratings)

    $40.00

    +$10.00 shipping · $50.00 total

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll Pleasant Company Truly Me Blonde Hair Brown Eyes Freckles 24

    American Girl Doll Pleasant Company Truly Me Blonde Hair Brown Eyes Freckles 24

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,510 ratings)

    $44.99

    +$12.99 shipping · $57.98 total

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Truly Me Doll Addy mold Medium Skin Curly Brown Hair Hazel Eyes

    American Girl Truly Me Doll Addy mold Medium Skin Curly Brown Hair Hazel Eyes

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,176 ratings)

    $47.00

    +$15.00 shipping · $62.00 total

    View at eBay
  • 18" American Girl Doll Today PC JLY Truly Me #3 Blonde Hair w/ Bangs, Blue Eyes

    18" American Girl Doll Today PC JLY Truly Me #3 Blonde Hair w/ Bangs, Blue Eyes

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (369 ratings)

    $69.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll Truly Me 24 Just Like You Blond hair Brown Eyes freckles

    American Girl Doll Truly Me 24 Just Like You Blond hair Brown Eyes freckles

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (425 ratings)

    $74.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay

Girl of the Year (6)

  • Retired 2015 American Girl of the Year 18" GRACE THOMAS Doll - Mark on Cheek

    Retired 2015 American Girl of the Year 18" GRACE THOMAS Doll - Mark on Cheek

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (116 ratings)

    $49.95

    +$15.20 shipping · $65.15 total

    View at eBay
  • Pre Owned American Girl Doll Grace Thomas Girl Of The Year 2015

    Pre Owned American Girl Doll Grace Thomas Girl Of The Year 2015

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (89 ratings)

    $70.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Summer McKinney 18" Doll 2025 Girl Of The Year

    American Girl Summer McKinney 18" Doll 2025 Girl Of The Year

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,315 ratings)

    $59.99

    +$21.90 shipping · $81.89 total

    View at eBay
  • 18" American Girl Doll 2014 GOTY Isabelle Palmer: Hazel Green Eyes, Blonde Hair

    18" American Girl Doll 2014 GOTY Isabelle Palmer: Hazel Green Eyes, Blonde Hair

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (5,783 ratings)

    $124.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll Lindsey Bergman Vintage Girl of the Year GOTY original owner

    American Girl Doll Lindsey Bergman Vintage Girl of the Year GOTY original owner

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (123 ratings)

    $175.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll GOTY Isabelle Hoffman Creative Dance Studio

    American Girl Doll GOTY Isabelle Hoffman Creative Dance Studio

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.6% positive (1,736 ratings)

    $200.00

    +$40.00 shipping · $240.00 total

    View at eBay

Historical Characters (6)

  • American Girl 18" Doll Julie Albright Blonde Hair Original Outfit 2011

    American Girl 18" Doll Julie Albright Blonde Hair Original Outfit 2011

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (931 ratings)

    $70.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Pleasant Company American Girl Doll Kit Kittredge Blond Bob Hair Meet Outfit

    Pleasant Company American Girl Doll Kit Kittredge Blond Bob Hair Meet Outfit

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.9% positive (7,449 ratings)

    $74.95

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll Emily Bennett Pleasant Company In Meet Dress

    American Girl Doll Emily Bennett Pleasant Company In Meet Dress

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,382 ratings)

    $88.00

    +$16.00 shipping · $104.00 total

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll Addy With New Head Original Meet Dress

    American Girl Doll Addy With New Head Original Meet Dress

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,359 ratings)

    $148.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll Nellie Strawberry Blonde Freckles Blue Eyes Bangs

    American Girl Doll Nellie Strawberry Blonde Freckles Blue Eyes Bangs

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (3,464 ratings)

    $199.99

    +$10.99 shipping · $210.98 total

    View at eBay
  • DREAMER EYES Early 90s Pleasant Company American Girl Doll Samantha PLEASE READ

    DREAMER EYES Early 90s Pleasant Company American Girl Doll Samantha PLEASE READ

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (47 ratings)

    $250.00

    +$18.00 shipping · $268.00 total

    View at eBay

Other listings (11)

  • American Girl 18 in Play Doll Dark Complexion, Brown Eyes, Wavy Dark Brown Hair

    American Girl 18 in Play Doll Dark Complexion, Brown Eyes, Wavy Dark Brown Hair

    Used · eBay

    $31.50

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll 18" Freckles brown hair 2014

    American Girl Doll 18" Freckles brown hair 2014

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.9% positive (19,710 ratings)

    $34.64

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll Pleasant Company

    American Girl Doll Pleasant Company

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (463 ratings)

    $39.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll 18" Medium Skin Brown Hair Green Eyes 2014 With Clothes
    eBay Top Rated Plus

    American Girl Doll 18" Medium Skin Brown Hair Green Eyes 2014 With Clothes

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (10,674 ratings)

    $39.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl 18 Inch Brown Eyes Brown Hair Doll 2014
    eBay Top Rated Plus

    American Girl 18 Inch Brown Eyes Brown Hair Doll 2014

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (3,435 ratings)

    $34.99

    +$8.50 shipping · $43.49 total

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll 18in Brown Hair Brown Eyes

    American Girl Doll 18in Brown Hair Brown Eyes

    Used · eBay

    $35.00

    +$10.00 shipping · $45.00 total

    View at eBay
  • American Girl doll Kit Summer Dress With Bow.

    American Girl doll Kit Summer Dress With Bow.

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (924 ratings)

    $49.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll Blonde Hair Blue Eyes Red Dress (READ BUYERS DESCRIPTION)

    American Girl Doll Blonde Hair Blue Eyes Red Dress (READ BUYERS DESCRIPTION)

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.9% positive (3,124 ratings)

    $49.99

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • American Girl Doll

    American Girl Doll

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.2% positive (391 ratings)

    $50.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Retired American Girl Doll of Today, Auburn Hair, Blue Eyes, Pleasant Co.

    Retired American Girl Doll of Today, Auburn Hair, Blue Eyes, Pleasant Co.

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (5,959 ratings)

    $35.99

    +$16.00 shipping · $51.99 total

    View at eBay
  • AMERICAN GIRL DOLL--Exclnt,   Free Shipping, in sturdy box.

    AMERICAN GIRL DOLL--Exclnt, Free Shipping, in sturdy box.

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.6% positive (11,461 ratings)

    $52.00

    Free shipping

    View at eBay

Price snapshot

Asking prices across 40 listings checked November 15, 2026, before shipping. The median is a good guide to a typical price; actual selling prices can be lower.

ModelListingsLowestMedianHighest
Custom Dolls6$64.97$105.00$165.00
Truly Me & Just Like You11$34.77$44.99$74.99
Girl of the Year6$49.95$97.00$200.00
Historical Characters6$70.00$118.00$250.00
Other listings11$31.50$39.00$52.00
All listings40$31.50$51.00$250.00