Rare Squishmallows
40 listings · $4.00–$499.99 · eBay, GameStop, Inc., Walmart, StockX · Prices checked November 15, 2026
Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Showing 40 of 40 listings
Jack the Black Cat (1)

Squishmallows Jack the Black Cat 12” RARE Original Select Series 500th NWT
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (125 ratings)
Avery the Duck (2)

Squishmallows Avery and Della Duck Plush Set Walgreens Exclusive Valentines Day
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (36 ratings)

New w/ Tags! Squishmallows 12" Avery the Duck FuzzAmallows Plush RARE HTF!
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (881 ratings)
Bigfoots (11)

Squishmallow Squeezemallow Zaylee The Bigfoot 7” Target Exclusive NWT
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (550 ratings)

Squishmallows Official 8 inch Caparinne the Bigfoot Stuffed Plush, Rare KellyToy Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal
New · Walmart

JOELLE the Bigfoot Squishmallow Fuzz A Mallow 12" Silver Tag RARE BRAND NEW
New · eBay · Seller 99.7% positive (9,892 ratings)

Kellytoy Squishmallows Benny The Big Foot Take 4 Exclusive 4" Plush w/Tags NWT
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,299 ratings)

Squishmallows 12” Joelle Fuzzamallow Teal Bigfoot RARE NWT Silver Tag
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,854 ratings)

SQUISHMALLOWS~new Woxie The Bigfoot Plush 10" Magenta~Tie-Dye Mane~NWT~Rare
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (14,708 ratings)

Squishmallows Brina The Bigfoot Pink Plush Collectors Tin Limited Edition New
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (2,422 ratings)

Squishmallows Wallis Ultra Rare Plush 8” Black Yeti Bigfoot Sunglasses Retired
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,854 ratings)

BNWT 8in Squishmallows Day Exclusive Sheba The Bigfoot/Highland Cow Squishmallow
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (127 ratings)

Rare Squishmallows Nanette the Shaggy Purple Bigfoot with Plush Yeti NEW Tag
New · eBay · Seller 99.9% positive (5,604 ratings)

Squishmallows Brina The Bigfoot Pink Plush Collectors Tin Limited Edition New
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (2,993 ratings)
Cows (5)

NWT RARE HTF Squishmallows Patton Cow 5” CANADIAN EXCLUSIVE Shoppers Christmas
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (15 ratings)

Squishmallows 12” Ronnie The Cow HTF RARE Easter 2021 Why Wait Buy Me Now
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (105 ratings)
eBay Top Rated PlusUlta Beauty Patty The Cow Squishmallows 5" Exclusive - NEW With Tags, Sealed
New · eBay · Seller 99.6% positive (16,969 ratings)

New w/ Tags! Squishmallows 12" Calynda Strawberry Cow Spotted Pink Plush RARE!
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (881 ratings)

RARE Squishmallows Borsa the Spotted Highland Cow 24” Plush NWT
New · eBay · Seller 97.7% positive (84 ratings)
FuzzAMallows (7)

Original Squishmallows 5" Tzeitel The Cat Fuzzamallows Walmart Exclusive
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,180 ratings)

Original Squishmallows 5" Azizbek The Red Onion Plush Fuzzamallows Exclusive
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,180 ratings)

Original Squishmallows 5" Kona The Sea Cow Fuzzamallows Plush Exclusive
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,180 ratings)

Original Squishmallows 5" Chase The Cat Fuzzamallows Plush Exclusive
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,180 ratings)

Squishmallows FuzzAmallows 12” Inch Brixton the Pink Sugar Glider W/Flower♡Rare
New · eBay · Seller 99.6% positive (926 ratings)

Squishmallows FuzzAmallows 16” Inch Triston the Chick with Bucket Hat Rare #3
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (647 ratings)

RARE Squishmallows FuzzAMallows Omar Bear Plush, Medium 16 in Washable Special
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (4 ratings)
Squishville Mini Plush (3)

Rare Pink Multicolour Cheetah ~ 2" Individual Squishville by Squishmallows
Used · eBay · Seller 99.2% positive (337 ratings)

Squishmallows Squishville Play & Display Oleta the Octopus 2" RARE EXCLUSIVE
New · Walmart

Squishmallows Squishville Play & Display Atoosa the Tiger 2" RARE EXCLUSIVE
New · Walmart
Other listings (11)

Squishmallows ALEXIE The Cow / Purple & Black / Limited Edition / 8”/
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (51 ratings)
eBay Top Rated PlusSquishmallows Kellytoy Disney Limited Edition 100th Anniversary Minnie Mouse 5"
Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (3,667 ratings)
Squishmallows Hybrid Exclusive Squad 5-in Plush Blind Bag
New · GameStop, Inc.

Kellytoy Squishmallow 8" Spencer The Dog Five Below Exclusive Soft Stuffed Plush
New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (596 ratings)

Squishmallows 5” Elida the Leopard - Ultrasoft Plush (Claire’s Exclusive)
Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (6,548 ratings)
Squishmallows Denali Blue Stegosaurus with Pink Scales 8-in Plush GameStop Exclusive
New · GameStop, Inc.
Squishmallows Sega Sonic the Hedgehog Dark Chao 8-in Plush GameStop Exclusive
New · GameStop, Inc.

Squishmallows Foodie Squad 7.5 in - Donnelly the Macaron Plush Rare
New · Walmart · 5.0★ (1 reviews)

Squishmallows - 8 Blacklight Exclusive Plush
New · Walmart · 4.9★ (26 reviews)

Squishmallows 8-Inch My Melody - Hello Kitty My Melody 2026 Limited Edition Christmas Plush - Collectible Stuffed Animal - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
New · Walmart · 4.8★ (37 reviews)

Squishmallow Pokemon Snorlax 12" Pokemon Center Exclusive Plush
New · StockX
Price snapshot
Asking prices across 40 listings checked November 15, 2026, before shipping. The median is a good guide to a typical price; actual selling prices can be lower.
| Model | Listings | Lowest | Median | Highest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jack the Black Cat | 1 | $499.99 | $499.99 | $499.99 |
| Avery the Duck | 2 | $25.00 | $27.49 | $29.99 |
| Bigfoots | 11 | $12.89 | $17.99 | $33.14 |
| Cows | 5 | $12.50 | $23.95 | $89.99 |
| FuzzAMallows | 7 | $8.49 | $12.99 | $195.00 |
| Squishville Mini Plush | 3 | $18.00 | $27.12 | $27.12 |
| Other listings | 11 | $4.00 | $9.97 | $39.00 |
| All listings | 40 | $4.00 | $16.97 | $499.99 |