Rare Squishmallows

40 listings · $4.00–$499.99 · eBay, GameStop, Inc., Walmart, StockX · Prices checked November 15, 2026

Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Model:
Condition:
Retailer:

Showing 40 of 40 listings

Jack the Black Cat (1)

  • Squishmallows Jack the Black Cat 12” RARE Original Select Series 500th NWT

    Squishmallows Jack the Black Cat 12” RARE Original Select Series 500th NWT

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (125 ratings)

    $499.99

    Free shipping

    View at eBay

Avery the Duck (2)

  • Squishmallows Avery and Della Duck Plush Set Walgreens Exclusive Valentines Day

    Squishmallows Avery and Della Duck Plush Set Walgreens Exclusive Valentines Day

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (36 ratings)

    $25.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • New w/ Tags! Squishmallows 12" Avery the Duck FuzzAmallows Plush RARE HTF!

    New w/ Tags! Squishmallows 12" Avery the Duck FuzzAmallows Plush RARE HTF!

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (881 ratings)

    $29.99

    +$7.99 shipping · $37.98 total

    View at eBay

Bigfoots (11)

  • Squishmallow Squeezemallow Zaylee The Bigfoot  7” Target Exclusive NWT

    Squishmallow Squeezemallow Zaylee The Bigfoot 7” Target Exclusive NWT

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (550 ratings)

    $12.89

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows Official 8 inch Caparinne the Bigfoot Stuffed Plush, Rare KellyToy Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal

    Squishmallows Official 8 inch Caparinne the Bigfoot Stuffed Plush, Rare KellyToy Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal

    New · Walmart

    $14.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • JOELLE the Bigfoot Squishmallow Fuzz A Mallow 12" Silver Tag RARE BRAND NEW

    JOELLE the Bigfoot Squishmallow Fuzz A Mallow 12" Silver Tag RARE BRAND NEW

    New · eBay · Seller 99.7% positive (9,892 ratings)

    $14.99

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Kellytoy Squishmallows Benny The Big Foot Take 4 Exclusive 4" Plush w/Tags NWT

    Kellytoy Squishmallows Benny The Big Foot Take 4 Exclusive 4" Plush w/Tags NWT

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,299 ratings)

    $14.99

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows 12” Joelle Fuzzamallow Teal Bigfoot RARE NWT Silver Tag

    Squishmallows 12” Joelle Fuzzamallow Teal Bigfoot RARE NWT Silver Tag

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,854 ratings)

    $17.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • SQUISHMALLOWS~new Woxie The Bigfoot Plush 10" Magenta~Tie-Dye Mane~NWT~Rare

    SQUISHMALLOWS~new Woxie The Bigfoot Plush 10" Magenta~Tie-Dye Mane~NWT~Rare

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (14,708 ratings)

    $15.95

    +$5.00 shipping · $20.95 total

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows Brina The Bigfoot Pink Plush Collectors Tin Limited Edition New

    Squishmallows Brina The Bigfoot Pink Plush Collectors Tin Limited Edition New

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (2,422 ratings)

    $21.99

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows Wallis Ultra Rare Plush 8” Black Yeti Bigfoot Sunglasses Retired

    Squishmallows Wallis Ultra Rare Plush 8” Black Yeti Bigfoot Sunglasses Retired

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,854 ratings)

    $24.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • BNWT 8in Squishmallows Day Exclusive Sheba The Bigfoot/Highland Cow Squishmallow

    BNWT 8in Squishmallows Day Exclusive Sheba The Bigfoot/Highland Cow Squishmallow

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (127 ratings)

    $25.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Rare Squishmallows Nanette the Shaggy Purple Bigfoot with Plush Yeti NEW Tag

    Rare Squishmallows Nanette the Shaggy Purple Bigfoot with Plush Yeti NEW Tag

    New · eBay · Seller 99.9% positive (5,604 ratings)

    $31.96

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows Brina The Bigfoot Pink Plush Collectors Tin Limited Edition New

    Squishmallows Brina The Bigfoot Pink Plush Collectors Tin Limited Edition New

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (2,993 ratings)

    $33.14

    Free shipping

    View at eBay

Cows (5)

  • NWT RARE HTF Squishmallows Patton Cow 5” CANADIAN EXCLUSIVE Shoppers Christmas

    NWT RARE HTF Squishmallows Patton Cow 5” CANADIAN EXCLUSIVE Shoppers Christmas

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (15 ratings)

    $12.50

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows 12” Ronnie The Cow HTF RARE Easter 2021 Why Wait Buy Me Now

    Squishmallows 12” Ronnie The Cow HTF RARE Easter 2021 Why Wait Buy Me Now

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (105 ratings)

    $20.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Ulta Beauty Patty The Cow Squishmallows 5" Exclusive - NEW With Tags, Sealed
    eBay Top Rated Plus

    Ulta Beauty Patty The Cow Squishmallows 5" Exclusive - NEW With Tags, Sealed

    New · eBay · Seller 99.6% positive (16,969 ratings)

    $23.95

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • New w/ Tags! Squishmallows 12" Calynda Strawberry Cow Spotted Pink Plush RARE!

    New w/ Tags! Squishmallows 12" Calynda Strawberry Cow Spotted Pink Plush RARE!

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (881 ratings)

    $29.99

    +$7.99 shipping · $37.98 total

    View at eBay
  • RARE Squishmallows Borsa the Spotted Highland Cow 24” Plush NWT

    RARE Squishmallows Borsa the Spotted Highland Cow 24” Plush NWT

    New · eBay · Seller 97.7% positive (84 ratings)

    $89.99

    +$9.99 shipping · $99.98 total

    View at eBay

FuzzAMallows (7)

  • Original Squishmallows 5" Tzeitel The Cat Fuzzamallows Walmart Exclusive

    Original Squishmallows 5" Tzeitel The Cat Fuzzamallows Walmart Exclusive

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,180 ratings)

    $8.49

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Original Squishmallows 5" Azizbek The Red Onion Plush Fuzzamallows Exclusive

    Original Squishmallows 5" Azizbek The Red Onion Plush Fuzzamallows Exclusive

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,180 ratings)

    $8.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Original Squishmallows 5" Kona The Sea Cow Fuzzamallows Plush Exclusive

    Original Squishmallows 5" Kona The Sea Cow Fuzzamallows Plush Exclusive

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,180 ratings)

    $11.39

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Original Squishmallows 5" Chase The Cat Fuzzamallows Plush Exclusive

    Original Squishmallows 5" Chase The Cat Fuzzamallows Plush Exclusive

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,180 ratings)

    $12.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows FuzzAmallows 12” Inch Brixton the Pink Sugar Glider W/Flower♡Rare

    Squishmallows FuzzAmallows 12” Inch Brixton the Pink Sugar Glider W/Flower♡Rare

    New · eBay · Seller 99.6% positive (926 ratings)

    $22.99

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows FuzzAmallows 16” Inch Triston the Chick with Bucket Hat Rare #3

    Squishmallows FuzzAmallows 16” Inch Triston the Chick with Bucket Hat Rare #3

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (647 ratings)

    $24.99

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • RARE Squishmallows FuzzAMallows Omar Bear Plush, Medium 16 in Washable Special

    RARE Squishmallows FuzzAMallows Omar Bear Plush, Medium 16 in Washable Special

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (4 ratings)

    $195.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay

Squishville Mini Plush (3)

  • Rare Pink Multicolour Cheetah ~ 2" Individual Squishville by Squishmallows

    Rare Pink Multicolour Cheetah ~ 2" Individual Squishville by Squishmallows

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.2% positive (337 ratings)

    $18.00

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows Squishville Play & Display Oleta the Octopus 2" RARE EXCLUSIVE

    Squishmallows Squishville Play & Display Oleta the Octopus 2" RARE EXCLUSIVE

    New · Walmart

    $27.12

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • Squishmallows Squishville Play & Display Atoosa the Tiger 2" RARE EXCLUSIVE

    Squishmallows Squishville Play & Display Atoosa the Tiger 2" RARE EXCLUSIVE

    New · Walmart

    $27.12

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart

Other listings (11)

  • Squishmallows ALEXIE The Cow / Purple & Black / Limited Edition / 8”/

    Squishmallows ALEXIE The Cow / Purple & Black / Limited Edition / 8”/

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (51 ratings)

    $4.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows Kellytoy Disney Limited Edition 100th Anniversary Minnie Mouse 5"
    eBay Top Rated Plus

    Squishmallows Kellytoy Disney Limited Edition 100th Anniversary Minnie Mouse 5"

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (3,667 ratings)

    $5.71

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows Hybrid Exclusive Squad 5-in Plush Blind Bag

    Squishmallows Hybrid Exclusive Squad 5-in Plush Blind Bag

    New · GameStop, Inc.

    $5.97

    Shipping not listed

    View at GameStop, Inc.
  • Kellytoy Squishmallow 8" Spencer The Dog Five Below Exclusive Soft Stuffed Plush

    Kellytoy Squishmallow 8" Spencer The Dog Five Below Exclusive Soft Stuffed Plush

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (596 ratings)

    $6.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows 5” Elida the Leopard - Ultrasoft Plush (Claire’s Exclusive)

    Squishmallows 5” Elida the Leopard - Ultrasoft Plush (Claire’s Exclusive)

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (6,548 ratings)

    $6.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Squishmallows Denali Blue Stegosaurus with Pink Scales 8-in Plush GameStop Exclusive

    Squishmallows Denali Blue Stegosaurus with Pink Scales 8-in Plush GameStop Exclusive

    New · GameStop, Inc.

    $9.97

    Shipping not listed

    View at GameStop, Inc.
  • Squishmallows Sega Sonic the Hedgehog Dark Chao 8-in Plush GameStop Exclusive

    Squishmallows Sega Sonic the Hedgehog Dark Chao 8-in Plush GameStop Exclusive

    New · GameStop, Inc.

    $10.98

    Shipping not listed

    View at GameStop, Inc.
  • Squishmallows Foodie Squad 7.5 in - Donnelly the Macaron Plush Rare

    Squishmallows Foodie Squad 7.5 in - Donnelly the Macaron Plush Rare

    New · Walmart · 5.0★ (1 reviews)

    $13.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • Squishmallows - 8 Blacklight Exclusive Plush

    Squishmallows - 8 Blacklight Exclusive Plush

    New · Walmart · 4.9★ (26 reviews)

    $14.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • Squishmallows 8-Inch My Melody - Hello Kitty My Melody 2026 Limited Edition Christmas Plush - Collectible Stuffed Animal - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys

    Squishmallows 8-Inch My Melody - Hello Kitty My Melody 2026 Limited Edition Christmas Plush - Collectible Stuffed Animal - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys

    New · Walmart · 4.8★ (37 reviews)

    $14.39

    Shipping not listed

    View at Walmart
  • Squishmallow Pokemon Snorlax 12" Pokemon Center Exclusive Plush

    Squishmallow Pokemon Snorlax 12" Pokemon Center Exclusive Plush

    New · StockX

    $39.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at StockX

Price snapshot

Asking prices across 40 listings checked November 15, 2026, before shipping. The median is a good guide to a typical price; actual selling prices can be lower.

ModelListingsLowestMedianHighest
Jack the Black Cat1$499.99$499.99$499.99
Avery the Duck2$25.00$27.49$29.99
Bigfoots11$12.89$17.99$33.14
Cows5$12.50$23.95$89.99
FuzzAMallows7$8.49$12.99$195.00
Squishville Mini Plush3$18.00$27.12$27.12
Other listings11$4.00$9.97$39.00
All listings40$4.00$16.97$499.99