Vintage My Little Pony

40 listings · $2.99–$200.00 · eBay · Prices checked November 15, 2026

Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Model:
Condition:

Showing 40 of 40 listings

Generation 2 (G2) (17)

  • My Little Pony G2 Magic Motion Sundance Vanity Mirror 1997

    My Little Pony G2 Magic Motion Sundance Vanity Mirror 1997

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,323 ratings)

    $2.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony MLP G2 SKY SKIMMER Gem Eyes 1997  Pink Butterfly RARE

    My Little Pony MLP G2 SKY SKIMMER Gem Eyes 1997 Pink Butterfly RARE

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (511 ratings)

    $6.47

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Hasbro G2 My Little Pony Tipsy Tulip Magic Motion Friend 1997

    Hasbro G2 My Little Pony Tipsy Tulip Magic Motion Friend 1997

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,070 ratings)

    $7.44

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Hasbro G2 My Little Pony Cupcake Secret Surprise 1997

    Hasbro G2 My Little Pony Cupcake Secret Surprise 1997

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,070 ratings)

    $7.44

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony MLP G2 SKY SKIMMER Gem Eyes 1997  Pink Butterfly RARE

    My Little Pony MLP G2 SKY SKIMMER Gem Eyes 1997 Pink Butterfly RARE

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.6% positive (282 ratings)

    $7.50

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony MLP G2 Sundance Sunsparkle Magic Motion Ponies VTG 1997 Figure

    My Little Pony MLP G2 Sundance Sunsparkle Magic Motion Ponies VTG 1997 Figure

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (4,825 ratings)

    $9.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Vintage 1997 My Little Pony MLP G2 Magic Motion Friends Sundance ~ READ

    Vintage 1997 My Little Pony MLP G2 Magic Motion Friends Sundance ~ READ

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.9% positive (12,878 ratings)

    $5.99

    +$5.99 shipping · $11.98 total

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony G2 1997 Berry Bright Hasbro MLP Secret Surprise Friends - Grapes

    My Little Pony G2 1997 Berry Bright Hasbro MLP Secret Surprise Friends - Grapes

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (57,535 ratings)

    $12.99

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony G2 Special Birthday Magic Light Heart 1997 Hasbro Vintage MLP

    My Little Pony G2 Special Birthday Magic Light Heart 1997 Hasbro Vintage MLP

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (2,048 ratings)

    $13.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony G2 Sky Skimmer Generation 2 Hasbro 1997 Vintage Gem Eyes

    My Little Pony G2 Sky Skimmer Generation 2 Hasbro 1997 Vintage Gem Eyes

    Used · eBay · Seller 96.5% positive (3,357 ratings)

    $14.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • MLP 1997 G2 "DAINTY DOVE" Diamond Eyes Wedding Bells Magic Motion Gem Eye

    MLP 1997 G2 "DAINTY DOVE" Diamond Eyes Wedding Bells Magic Motion Gem Eye

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,037 ratings)

    $15.00

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Vintage My Little Pony  Clever Clover G2 1997

    Vintage My Little Pony Clever Clover G2 1997

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (3,465 ratings)

    $15.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony G2 Orange Pony Confetti Symbols Pink Yellow Hair Vintage

    My Little Pony G2 Orange Pony Confetti Symbols Pink Yellow Hair Vintage

    Used · eBay · Seller 98.8% positive (601 ratings)

    $15.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony, G1 and G2, Multi-Listing, Pick Your Pony, Vintage Toys.

    My Little Pony, G1 and G2, Multi-Listing, Pick Your Pony, Vintage Toys.

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (4,390 ratings)

    $10.00

    +$6.75 shipping · $16.75 total

    View at eBay
  • Vintage My Little Pony G2 Berry Bright 1997 MLP Secret Surprise Friends Grapes

    Vintage My Little Pony G2 Berry Bright 1997 MLP Secret Surprise Friends Grapes

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.7% positive (2,601 ratings)

    $17.00

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony Secret Surprise Cupcake G2 Pink Vintage 1990s Adorable

    My Little Pony Secret Surprise Cupcake G2 Pink Vintage 1990s Adorable

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.7% positive (2,601 ratings)

    $17.27

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Vintage My Little Pony G2 Berry Bright (See Description)

    Vintage My Little Pony G2 Berry Bright (See Description)

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (856 ratings)

    $18.00

    Free shipping

    View at eBay

Generation 1 (G1) (17)

  • Vintage 1983 Hasbro Windy G1 My Little Pony Unicorn Rainbow Hair Glittery Swirl

    Vintage 1983 Hasbro Windy G1 My Little Pony Unicorn Rainbow Hair Glittery Swirl

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (152 ratings)

    $10.50

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Vintage 1982 G1 My Little Pony "SNUZZLE" Gray with Pink Hearts MLP

    Vintage 1982 G1 My Little Pony "SNUZZLE" Gray with Pink Hearts MLP

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (97 ratings)

    $12.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Vintage 1984 My Little Pony G1 CELEBRATE (Pretty ‘N Pearly Baby Sea Ponies)

    Vintage 1984 My Little Pony G1 CELEBRATE (Pretty ‘N Pearly Baby Sea Ponies)

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (152 ratings)

    $12.50

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • 1984 MY LITTLE PONY G1 BABY STOCKINGS MAIL-ORDER CHRISTMAS PONY

    1984 MY LITTLE PONY G1 BABY STOCKINGS MAIL-ORDER CHRISTMAS PONY

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,037 ratings)

    $12.75

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Sleepy Beddy Bye Eye Ponies Baby Heart Throb Pegasus My Little Pony G1 1986

    Sleepy Beddy Bye Eye Ponies Baby Heart Throb Pegasus My Little Pony G1 1986

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (1,369 ratings)

    $12.75

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • VINTAGE 1987 G1 My Little Pony "Sundae Best" - SHERBET Purple Pink Hasbro MLP

    VINTAGE 1987 G1 My Little Pony "Sundae Best" - SHERBET Purple Pink Hasbro MLP

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (3,315 ratings)

    $8.95

    +$5.95 shipping · $14.90 total

    View at eBay
  • Vintage My Little Pony Vintage G1 Baby Sea Pony Sea Star
    eBay Top Rated Plus

    Vintage My Little Pony Vintage G1 Baby Sea Pony Sea Star

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (4,447 ratings)

    $14.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony MLP Vintage Pegasus Heart Throb #11 VERY GOOD glittery symbols G1

    My Little Pony MLP Vintage Pegasus Heart Throb #11 VERY GOOD glittery symbols G1

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (9,272 ratings)

    $8.99

    +$7.50 shipping · $16.49 total

    View at eBay
  • Vintage My Little Pony G1 Baby Sparkle Pony Baby Starflower 1984 80’s

    Vintage My Little Pony G1 Baby Sparkle Pony Baby Starflower 1984 80’s

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (193 ratings)

    $18.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Rose: My Little Pony MLP Vintage Rainbow Unicorn Windy #2 EXCELLENT glittery G1

    Rose: My Little Pony MLP Vintage Rainbow Unicorn Windy #2 EXCELLENT glittery G1

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (9,272 ratings)

    $10.99

    +$7.50 shipping · $18.49 total

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony Vintage Collector Pose Concave Foot Blue Belle #5 VERY GOOD G1

    My Little Pony Vintage Collector Pose Concave Foot Blue Belle #5 VERY GOOD G1

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (9,272 ratings)

    $11.99

    +$7.50 shipping · $19.49 total

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony MLP Vintage Newborn Twin Unicorn Baby Sniffles #4 NEAR MINT G1

    My Little Pony MLP Vintage Newborn Twin Unicorn Baby Sniffles #4 NEAR MINT G1

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (9,272 ratings)

    $11.99

    +$7.50 shipping · $19.49 total

    View at eBay
  • (4) My Little Pony G1 Petite Ponies Ponytail Ponies Complete Set 2

    (4) My Little Pony G1 Petite Ponies Ponytail Ponies Complete Set 2

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,459 ratings)

    $19.90

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Vintage Green Melody 1983 My Little Pony MLP G1 Pegasus W Music Notes

    Vintage Green Melody 1983 My Little Pony MLP G1 Pegasus W Music Notes

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.7% positive (4,654 ratings)

    $19.95

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • 1980’s Fashion Doll Combs & Brushes Vintage BARBIE & My Little Pony G1 Authentic

    1980’s Fashion Doll Combs & Brushes Vintage BARBIE & My Little Pony G1 Authentic

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,305 ratings)

    $19.95

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • My Little Pony G1 Big Brother Slugger #1

    My Little Pony G1 Big Brother Slugger #1

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (17,976 ratings)

    $19.99

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Vintage 1989 G1 My Little Pony Bridal Beauty White Wedding Pony Glitter Hair
    eBay Top Rated Plus

    Vintage 1989 G1 My Little Pony Bridal Beauty White Wedding Pony Glitter Hair

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (3,743 ratings)

    $20.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay

Other listings (6)

  • Rare Vintage 1985 My Little Pony 10th Anniversary Birthday Tinsel Pony

    Rare Vintage 1985 My Little Pony 10th Anniversary Birthday Tinsel Pony

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (4,701 ratings)

    $14.99

    +$5.90 shipping · $20.89 total

    View at eBay
  • Vintage My Little Pony Tennis Accessories Pony Wear 1986 Hasbro NOS Racquet New

    Vintage My Little Pony Tennis Accessories Pony Wear 1986 Hasbro NOS Racquet New

    New · eBay · Seller 100% positive (11,777 ratings)

    $30.00

    Free shipping

    View at eBay
  • Vintage My Little Pony Baby Crumpet 1987 First Tooth

    Vintage My Little Pony Baby Crumpet 1987 First Tooth

    Used · eBay · Seller 100% positive (1,679 ratings)

    $30.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • Vtg 1981 Hasbro My Pretty Pony G0 Precursor MLP Brown Horse WORKING Eyes Ears

    Vtg 1981 Hasbro My Pretty Pony G0 Precursor MLP Brown Horse WORKING Eyes Ears

    Used · eBay · Seller 99.9% positive (2,927 ratings)

    $79.99

    +$10.50 shipping · $90.49 total

    View at eBay
  • Vtg My Little Pony New Shower Curtain & Shower Curtain Hooks New In Package

    Vtg My Little Pony New Shower Curtain & Shower Curtain Hooks New In Package

    New · eBay · Seller 99.8% positive (2,932 ratings)

    $99.00

    Shipping not listed

    View at eBay
  • ❤️‍🔥NIP VTG Gen 1 My Little Pony "Baby Fancy Pants Pony" set Baby Sunnybunch

    ❤️‍🔥NIP VTG Gen 1 My Little Pony "Baby Fancy Pants Pony" set Baby Sunnybunch

    New · eBay · Seller 99.4% positive (964 ratings)

    $200.00

    Free shipping

    View at eBay

Price snapshot

Asking prices across 40 listings checked November 15, 2026, before shipping. The median is a good guide to a typical price; actual selling prices can be lower.

ModelListingsLowestMedianHighest
Generation 2 (G2)17$2.99$12.99$18.00
Generation 1 (G1)17$8.95$12.75$20.00
Other listings6$14.99$55.00$200.00
All listings40$2.99$14.49$200.00